I don’t believe in the X Factor, the programme, or the definition of someone having said X Factor. The X Factor is so much more difficult to define than a teenager with a wacky haircut and the latest warble to be deemed fashionable by multi-millionaires with a heartfelt passion for a certain part of the music business (that being the business part!)
I read an interesting article about getting a thousand loyal fans in order to make your musical career sustainable. May not seem like a lot of people but it really is. If you play to 100 people in a night, I reckon 10% will take an interest/compliment you/want to know more. Of those 10, probably 10% will take it further. Therefore, if my maths serve, 1000 gigs will get you 1000 fans, if you’re lucky and work like a lunatic.
But if you’re a teenage desperate who has made it to the big X Factor shows, it’s all there. You do passable, sometimes terrible, occasionally great versions of karaoke favourites, thus appealing to the watching masses music-wise. You’ve already bypassed the need to connect socially with prospective fans via the internet or by other means because your emotional rise to the top has been documented in the series, plus you’ll be splattered all over the tabloids so everyone already feels a connection with you. If you win your CD makes it into the record shop and onto the interweb thanks to the all powerful machine backing you up. If you’re a runner up there’s still a chance your album will make it onto the supermarket shelves. I now browse the CD section and see completely unfamiliar faces next to Michael Jackson and the Kings of Leon with inspiring album titles like ‘This Time’ and ‘Believe’ with one new formulaic song and 10 cover versions. It’s a brilliant setup – genius! It totalIy bypasses the uncertainty of where your next fan is coming from. I’m not belittling the people who make it to the finals – it is immensely hard work performing in any way. I also applaud the makers and the panel for creating something that draws people in, gets the whole nation debating and on the edge of their seats and makes them lots of money whilst bringing some young hopeful’s dream to fruition for a month or two.
The only problem I have with this fruitful setup is with the other side of the music business – the music side. I briefly saw a panel show, Xtra Factor or something and Joss Stone was commenting about the programme being all about the singing. It’s not. It’s about drama. It’s about ‘is Cheryl going to cry this week?’; ‘is Louis going to walk out again?’; ‘is one of the contestants going to swing for Cowell?’ The panel are the only real celebrities on the show, the only famous ones, and probably the only ones with the X Factor – in their case the X Factor being their ‘Panel Personality Traits’. Oh, and Dermot (lovely, lovely Dermot.) And it’s the drama of the contestant’s struggle, how they have progressed in just 6 short weeks, caterpillar to butterfly, what they had to go through or sacrifice to reach the final – who needs Eastenders? But it’s not about music. It’s not about a song you can listen to for 20 years and still love passionately. It’s not about a band that you grow with and love more every time you see them live, watch a video, find out they are lovely as well as brilliant. If you want music, watch Later…With Jools Holland – a programme I always, and I mean always, love when I see it because of it’s diversity and for it’s unashamed love of just watching people performing.
The X Factor is great television. And what, I hear you cry, has it done for music? Well, the X Factor is great television.
The point of this rant? The next time someone says, ‘you’re a musician? Why don’t you go on X Factor?’, I shall perhaps reply, ‘because I’m a musician’ or I shall perhaps direct them to this post.
And to you, the X Factor viewer. Do me a favour, instead of watching it next week, try one or all of these ACTUAL MUSICIANS instead. You don’t have to go out to find them (links included) but you do have to put more effort in than just sitting with the remote and a bag of Maltesers (mmmmmm, Maltesers, sounds good!)
Here’s 13 bands/singers and their links that I have discovered on my travels that I love or find interesting and think you should try discovering too:
Josh Rouse
http://www.myspace.com/joshrouse
Gemma Hayes
http://www.myspace.com/gemmahayes
Sad Day For Puppets
http://www.myspace.com/saddayforpuppets
Hope & Social
http://www.hopeandsocial.com/
Sketches
http://www.myspace.com/sketchesband
Bell X1
http://www.bellx1.com/
Dave Thorne
http://www.myspace.com/thedavethorne
Matt Costa
http://www.mattcosta.com/home
Ahmond
http://www.myspace.com/ahmondband
Bent
http://www.bent-world.com/site2/home/
Angus & Julia Stone
http://www.angusandjuliastone.com/a_book_like_this/index.htm
The Swell Season
http://www.myspace.com/theswellseason
The Milk And Honey Band
http://www.myspace.com/themilkandhoneyband
November 16, 2009
Categories: General . Tags: Ahmond, Angus & Julia Stone, Bell X1, Bent, cheryl cole, cheryl tweedy, dannii minogue, Dave Thorne, Dermot O'Leary, desperate, fan, fans, formulaic, Gemma Hayes, gig, Gigs, great television, Hope & Social, Jools Holland, Josh Rouse, karaoke, Later..., Later...With Jools Holland, louis walsh, maltesers, Matt Costa, Music, musician, Sad Day For Puppets, simon cowell, Sketches, struggle, teenage, television, The Milk And Honey Band, The Swell Season, x factor, xtra factor . Author: coostickshq . Comments: Leave a Comment